| 1868 Joseph White | 1921 S.C. Hutchinson | 1975 Joseph H. Gibbons |
| 1869 Joseph White, Daniel Leach | 1922 Ernest W. Butterfield | 1976 Hugh M. Watson |
| 1870 John D. Philbrick | 1923 Harvey S. Gruver | 1977 Charles B. Johnson |
| 1871 Abner J. Phipps, Charles Morrills | 1924 Willard H. Bacon | 1978 Wendall G. Eaton |
| 1872 Daniel Leach, Eli A. Hubbard | 1925 Betram E. Packard | 1979 Henry J. McLaughlin |
| 1873 Gilbert E. Hood, Benjamin F. Tweed | 1926 Burr J. Merriam | 1980 John K. Boyle |
| 1874 Admiral P. Stone, Henry F. Harrington | 1927 Carroll R. Reed | 1981 John A. Waters |
| 1875 Charles Morrill, William W. Waterman | 1928 Carroll H. White | 1982 Thomas J. Pene |
| 1876 Francis Cogswell, Warren Johnson | 1929 William B. Jack | 1983 Robert E. Dikon |
| 1877 Joshua H. Davis, John D. Philbrick | 1930 Louis P. Benezie | 1984 Mark F. Keegan |
| 1878 J.T. Allard, A.P Marble | 1931 Charles F. Towne | 1985 Peter G. Dolloff |
| 1879 Thamas Tash, J.G. Edgerly | 1932 Hector L. Beslisle | 1986 Joseph J. Picano |
| 1880 Augustus D. Small, E. Hunt | 1934 Warren A. Hanson | 1987 Lincoln D. Lynch |
| 1881 S.W. Mason, T.B. Stockwell | 1935 Lyman C. Hunt | 1988 Lawrence R. Miller |
| 1882 Francis W. Parker, F.D. Davis | 1936 George R. Gardner | 1989 Joseph S. Kasprazak |
| 1883 D.H. Daniels, Edwin P. Seaver | 1937 Harry L. Moore | 1990 Richard E. Marx |
| 1884 John L. Brewster, O.B. Bruce | 1938 Harold T. Lowe | 1991 Edgar R. Melanson |
| 1885 L.H. Marvel, G.C. Fisher | 1939 Ernest W. Fellows | 1992 John W. DeGoes |
| 1886 G.I. Aldrich, S.T. Dutton | 1940 Fred D. Wish, Jr. | 1993 Thomas J. Cullen |
| 1887 Thomas Emerson, W.E. Hatch | 1941 Guy W. Powers | 1994 Joseph J. Cirasuolo |
| 1888 Henry Whittemore, George A. Littlefield | 1942 Harry C. Hull | 1995 Alice W. Angney |
| 1889 J.W. Patterson, Wilhelmina C. Bates | 1943 Earle T. Gray | 1996 Stanley J. Sawyer |
| 1890 H.S. Tarbell, I. Freeman Hall | 1944 Clarence W. Boswort | 1997 Richard V. Lates |
| 1891 E. L. Kirtland, G.H. Danforth | 1945 John J. Desmond, Jr. | 1998 Maureen Chevrette |
| 1892 A.F. Pease, C.F. Meleney | 1946 Lloyd H. Bugbee | 1999 Paul A. Squarcia |
| 1893 Channing Folsom, N.I. Bishop | 1947 Lyman W. Bole | 2000 David A. Cressy |
| 1894 I.C. Phillips, G. C. Fisher | 1948 Joseph A. Leonard | 2001 Greg Scieszka, Jr. |
| 1895 A.W. Edson, J.C. Simpson | 1949 Caleb H. Niles | 2002 James A. Ashe |
| 1896 Mason S. Stone, Louis P. Nast | 1950 James L. Haney | 2003 Lyonel B. Tracy |
| 1897 Fred Gowing, H.W. Lull | 1951 Starr M. King | 2004 Richard Scherza |
| 1898 William D. Parkinson | 1952 Walter P. Sweet | 2005 Thomas Y. McDowell |
| 1899 Mary S. Snow | 1953 Allen J. Heath | 2006 Thomas Y. McDowell |
| 1900 Walter H. Small | 1954 Roland J. Carpenter | 2007 Randall Collins, Thomas Y. McDowell |
| 1901 Roscoe D. McKeen | 1955 Laurence O. Thompson | 2008 Brenda Needham |
| 1902 Randall J. Condon, Giles A. Stuart | 1956 James E. Conlon | 2009 Marjorie Chiafery |
| 1903 Asher J. Jacoby | 1957 Charles R. Thibadeau | 2010 David W. Murphy |
| 1904 T.W. Harris | 1958 Albert P. Mathers | 2011 Donald J. Beaudette |
| 1905 B.B. Russell | 1959 Lloyd W. Moulton | 2012 Roy Seitsinger |
| 1906 Stratton D. Brooks | 1960 Lawrence A. Peake | 2013 John Tindall-Gibson |
| 1908 Henry D. Hervey | 1961 Lewis F. Foote | 2014 Nathan S. Greenberg, David W. Murphy |
| 1909 F. H. Beede | 1962 Aaron F. Demoranville | 2015 Robert Gerardi, Thomas J. Lynch |
| 1910 Frank O. Drapper | 1963 Aura W. Coleman | 2016 Mario Andrade, Roy Seitsinger |
| 1911 Bernard M. Sheridan | 1964 William H. Curtis | 2017 Michael Emmitt |
| 1912 Arthur Derin Call | 1965 Theodore D. Sargent | 2018 Beth Cobb, Jeanné Collins |
| 1913 David Snedden | 1966 J. Weldon Russell | 2019 Beth Cobb, Jeanné Collins |
| 1914 Stanley H. Holmes | 1967 Frederick C. Walker | 2020 Andrew Corey |
| 1915 Valetine Almy | 1968 Edward S. Fitzgerald | 2021 David Murphy |
| 1916 George L. Farley | 1969 Arthur W. Dalrymple | 2022 Anna Nolin |
| 1917 John D. DeMeyer | 1970 Edison E. Phelps | 2023 Colleen Burns Jermain |
| 1918 Fred H. Nickerson | 1972 John L. Houston | |
| 1919 Henry H. Randall | 1973 Andrew A. Dominic | |
| 1920 Samuel J. Slawson | 1974 Edward R. Martin | |
